Let's play a game. Imagine you are suddenly hit by a severe case of fashion amnesia. To you, fall conjures up the earthy smell of fallen leaves, the name Ghesquiere evokes an obscure variety of fish and the word peplum has never graced your lips. You ready?
Now, open your eyes wide, soak in the curated content below and tell me in all honesty whether your highly trained eye (you are amnesic, not devoid from critical senses!) would be able to attribute these dramatic frills to more than one maison. I for one could not. All I see is sculptural ruffles punctuating the seams of otherwise overtly minimalistic pieces. Thrilling bichromatic frills that may be flouncy by essence, but are neither girly or prissy in the execution. One big happy family.
But I would be wrong. And there's a good chance you would to (are you?).
This is not me just being facetious. I am genuinely intrigued as to how this happens. Because if plagiarism is the ethos of our age, surely even a born skeptical would have to agree that unless Ghesquiere (the creative genius, not the scaly creature with gills) and Tisci spent last season sending spying Oompa Loompa's to each other's workshop, these conclusive similarities are pure coincidence.
But how? If ruffles have kept to themselves since the 80s, why is it that in September 2013 our runways suddenly went wild for the shape? It's not just Givenchy and Balenciaga - although their renditions seem the most incestuous. Chloé, Gucci, JW Anderson and Marni are all at it too. And suddenly ruffles are vying for first place in the run-up for Trend of the Season and even I, a born and bred conservative dresser
have welcomed their exuberant maximalism into my wardrobe.
I struggle to comprehended the workings of trends. I hear it has something to do with trend forecasters. If fashion ever had a god, I suppose they would get the crown. I wish I understood how it worked. If anyone knows, pray do explain.
Have you finished yet? Remember, the rules are simple: no Style.com peeking. I wish I could write the answers upside down as they do in kids magazines, but such is not in my skill set. Instead, I will daringly ask you to play favourites. If there are to be two sides, then surely a ruffle-off is a given. Fire away.
(Ph/Harper's Bazaar, Style.com, Marie Claire, Vogue UK, Balenciaga, Givenchy)